BLACK BOXES (Only A Part of the Article Appears Here)
…… BY BIMAL K. SRIVASTAVA
An Air
India B-747 (Jumbo Jet) aircraft while on a flight from Mumbai to Dubai fell into the Arabian sea, two minutes after its take-off
from Mumbai. The pilot had not passed any emergency message on Radio and everything appeared to be normal before the accident.
So much so , even the pilot had conveyed new years greetings (It was 1st January night) on radio to the Radar Controller on
ground a few seconds before crash.
However
the accident took place and the Jumbo hit the sea with such an impact that the total aircraft got embedded into sea bottom
(The depth of water was hardly 10-15 meters at that place), resulting into a watery burial and sudden death for all the 213
occupants of the ill fated aircraft. Unfortunately, since it was a winter night, there were hardly any witnesses to the mishap.
Finally
Indian Navy and the local fishermen were able to search the wreckage (and could retrieve the black boxes) after three days.
On re-play of the black boxes it was established that the "Attitude Direction Indicator (ADI)" instrument that provides the
information about the attitude of the aircraft (its bank, pitch, direction etc)
had failed resulting into disaster.
From the
above example it is evident that the black boxes play a very important role in aircraft accident investigation. That is why
whenever an aircraft accident occurs, the first and foremost job (of course other than search and rescue) is that to locate
the black boxes.
WHAT ARE
BLACK BOXES.
The black
boxes are special instruments (in the shape of rectangular boxes) which continuously record the flight details and the cockpit
conversation during flight. Black boxes are not one but TWO separate instruments known as "Cockpit Voice Recorder (CVR)" and
"Flight Data Recorder (FDR)" respectively.
CVR and
FDR, though entirely separate instruments, yet externally they almost look alike (in shape, size and colour). Moreover, though
these instruments are called Black Boxes, they are normally bright red or orange in colour. The name `BLACK
BOX' has been given to them, perhaps due to the fact that the information contained inside these units is not known unless
and until the unit is played on a special recorder.
These
units are contained in strong rectangular metallic boxes which are capable of withstanding high degree of shock and extensive
heat arising as a result of aircraft crash (Manufacturers term them as crash-proof). They can also resist heavy rain, fire
or any other odd of this nature. The normal size of a black box is 13 X 20 X 30 cms and its weight is about 10 KGs. Thus they
are comparable to a brief case in shape and size. Normally these boxes are installed towards the rear portion of the aircraft,
as it is believed that this area of the aircraft is less prone to damage during an accident.
Inside
the tough boxes, the soft and delicate tape is sheltered that actually performs the important job of recording flight details
and cockpit conversation. This tape is either a magnetic tape or a thin metallic foil. It is surprising that even after such
heavy impact, fire, extensive heat, or continuous contact with water, the metallic boxes provide a perfect shielding to the
vulnerable tape; and normally the recordings do not suffer damage.
The black
boxes start functioning as soon as the aircraft engines are started and they stop when all the engines are shut down.
Black
boxes are fitted with a typical sound transmitters operated by a special battery, which is known as acoustic underwater locator
beacon assembly. This unit is a battery-powered device, which radiates pulsed
acoustic signals into the surrounding water upon activation of its water sensitive switch.
The beacon consists of a self-contained battery in electronic module and a transducer.
The water sensitive switch gets activated whenever it comes in contact with water (either sweet water or saline water).
This may
happen in the event of the aircraft falling into sea, lake or river, when the transmitter starts operating and a peculiar
"Beep Beep" sound is produced on a regular and continuous basis that can be heard from a distance of 3 kms (of course by means
of special receivers). Once `on' the battery continues working for about 30 days. The idea is that that aircraft wreckage
even submerged in water can be searched by the help of this sound.
It may
be mentioned that the CVR and FDR of Air India Jumbo jet "Kanishka" that had fallen into Irish sea on 23rd June 85, could
be located and retrieved from a deep sea-bed of more than 2000 meters by combined efforts of the naval fleets of Canada, Britain,
Ireland and France through the help of these sound transmitters, which otherwise would have been impossible to get.
COCKPIT
VOICE RECORDER (CVR)
Cockpit
Voice Recorder (CVR) enables in presenting the recorded voice conversation of crewmembers of the aircraft. Its primary purpose
is to provide valuable evidence in determining the cause of an aircraft accident, however, it can be used for other purposes
also such as Incident Investigation, checking the performance of Crew Members, computing the speed of Engines and Propellers,
routine monitoring of aircraft data etc. In India it is mandatory for all turbine-powered aeroplanes of 5700 KGs and above
to have CVR fitted.
.........
...........
...........
.............
The four tracks of the CVR (termed
as Channel 1, 2, 3, or 4) record either transmitted or received signals that originate typically at various crewmember stations
or that of Area Microphones. Normally Channel 1 record communications received and transmitted on Flight Engineers head set.
However in case of the aircraft which do not have Flight Engineer's position such as Boeing 737, A-320 etc., Channel 1 records
Cabin Crew communications (including
.........
.........
.........
For example,
in 1974 one Lufthansa B747 aircraft crashed in the Nairobi when its CVR was read out, it was found that the pilot had forgotten
to extend the leading edge flaps during take-off check list, and therefore the aircraft could not derive adequate lift causing
it to crash. The cause of this accident could be established only because of
the CVR Tape transcript.
Similarly
when the CVR of the Air India B747 aircraft "Emperor Ashoka' that had crashed near Mumbai on 1-1-78 was played back, the following
cockpit conversation was heard:
- "My Instruments are toppled"...(Captain)
- "Mine is also toppled"...(Co-pilot)
- "No but, go by that Captain"...(Flight Engineer)
Due to
that it could be later established that the aircraft had crashed due to failure of pilots "Altitude Director Indicator (ADI)"
that gives the information about the altitude of the aircraft during Flight
...............
.................
.................
For example
during the investigation of an accident pertaining to an aircraft which was delayed and was departing very late during night,
the CVR transcript revealed that the pilot was telling to his co-pilot
"Yaar
Mujhe Bahut Neend Aaa rahi hai"
(I
am feeling very sleepy)
This clearly showed the mental state of crewmember who was undertaking the flight at such an
odd hours.
Similarly
sometimes the CVR showed that the crewmembers were in a very light and jovial mood occasionally to the extent of not paying
much attention towards the flight. In one of the accident, it was found that
the commander who happened to be a close relative of the trainee pilot, also going for his supernumery flight, was so much
engrossed in explaining to him the flight procedures, that he almost forgot about many vital points to be observed during
the crucial phase of landing. This aircraft ultimately crashed on a hill at a
stage when the crewmembers were least aware of the obstruction ahead. On the
other hand, many times, the flight crewmembers are found very sincere and they follow all the procedures and checklist thoroughly.
FLIGHT
DATA RECORDER (FDR)
The other
black boxes viz. FDR records flight details such as aircraft speed, altitude, direction, gravity, and rate of climb/ descent
and time. It normally contains a metallic tape on which the information gets permanently engraved by a special probe (like
a gramophone needle). Its tape can run for 25 hours of flight and then a new tape is installed.
FDR provides
valuable information about the aircraft and its flight. For example the time of accident can be exactly pinpointed. Similarly
it can also be known whether speed, altitude of the aircraft were normal or any abnormality was noticed. If, so what could
be the cause of that and so on.
In modern
aircraft like Jumbo jet (B-747), Airbus, A320 etc. a new type of computerised flight data recorder called Digital Flight Data
..........
................
.................
(BIMAL K. SRIVASTAVA)